BBB Reveals Most Complained About Industries

By Bizclik Editor

We all know that unsatisfied customers usually have no qualms about voicing their displeasure, but they don’t always research a business’s reputation before handing over their money. According to the Better Business Bureau, consumer and shopping savvy is on an upswing, as the organization received a record amount of contacts for consultation and considerably less formal complaints in 2011.

Last year, consumers came to BBB more than 103 million times for help or information, up 18 percent over 2010. BBB hasn’t seen that much positive action in its entire 100-year history. Formal complaints against businesses dropped from just over one million in 2010 to 927,000 across the US and Canada.

Those figures suggest that consumers not only trust BBB’s system, which includes grading businesses based on complaint histories, responsiveness to customers and legal and government action, but also that they are empowering themselves by becoming educated about where they choose to take their business.

“When consumers come to us first for information about businesses, they are much less likely to need our dispute resolution services later,” said Council of Better Business Bureaus CEO Carrie A. Hurt.

Contracting was the top industry for inquiries, followed closely by used auto dealers, auto repair and service and plumbers. Used auto dealers have never been able to boast a trustworthy reputation, but their presence on the list, as with the other industries, suggests that consumers are looking to minimize risk when making big purchases.

 “People tend to do more research when they are spending a lot of money, such as on homes and cars,” Hurt said.



2011 Total Inquiries  Rank by number of Inquiries1 Percentage Change over 2010 
Roofing Contractors   3,343,214  1 38.8% 
Contractors – General   2,232,022  2 71.4% 
Auto Dealers – Used Cars   1,606,226  3 40.6% 
Auto Repair & Service   1,581,440  4 63.8% 
Plumbers   1,524,559  5 49.9% 
Auto Dealers – New Cars 1,517,950 6 26%
Mortgage Brokers 1,471,565 7 14.5%
Construction & Remodeling Services 1,293,423 8 36.4%
Heating & Air Conditioning 1,227,787 9 19.4%
Movers 1,205,158 10 3.3%

When BBB receives a complaint about a business from a consumer, the formal procedure that follows gives the company 30 days to respond. BBB says that about 95 percent of complaints are resolved at this point and the rest must go to mediation or arbitration. Cellphone dealers caused consumers the most grief in 2011. Complaints about that industry were up nearly 41 percent from 2010. Television companies came in at number three with 25,518 complaints, but that’s actually an improvement of 17.6 percent from the previous year.

BBB says these results aren’t a shock since these industries provide services we all use frequently.

“Even though the volume of complaints is high, the actual rate of complaints is relatively low. And companies in these industries also tend to resolve complaints at a higher rate, as well,” said Hurt.

After the clamor of the Occupy Wall Street movement, it is surprising that bank complaints dropped 29 percent, loans were down 35 percent and complaints about mortgage brokers fell 31 percent.

The least improvement award goes to payday loan companies—complaints about that industry rose 159 percent in 2011. 

Industry  2011 Total Complaints Rank by number of Complaints1  Percentage Change over 2010 Percentage of Resolved Complaints 2
Cellular Telephone Service & Equipment  38,420  1  40.8%  96.1%
Auto Dealers – New Cars  25,983  2 5.2%  87.8% 
Television – Cable, CATV & Satellite  25,518  3 -17.6%  97.8% 
Collection Agencies  18,090  4 13.9%  83.1% 
Auto Dealers – Used Cars  16,264  5 12%  72.9% 
Banks 15,989 6 -29.4% 97.5%
Telephone Companies 15,691 7 65.2% 96.3%
Furniture – Retail 14,521 8 11.5% 75.3%
Auto Repair & Service 14,490 9 10% 66.7%
Internet Shopping 12,877 10 -.6% 71.9%

*Charts compiled by BBB


Featured Articles

Top 20 essential leadership resources for Black executives

To celebrate Black History Month, here are 20 resources for Black leaders – from business books to leadership coaches to business school exec programs

Broadridge study reveals huge impact of AI on C-suite

Broadridge Financial Solutions spoke to 500 C-suite executives from across the globe, many of whom said AI was significantly changing the way they work

PwC's Kathryn Kaminsky – the role of boards on social issues

As Vice Chair Trust Solutions Co-Leader at PwC, Kathryn Kaminsky says boards play an important role in helping businesses take action on social issues

Why your business needs a Chief Transformation Officer

Leadership & Strategy

12 top AI and ML trends for the enterprise in 2023 – Dataiku

Technology & AI

From NYC to Hong Kong, the rise of the private members' club

Leadership & Strategy